I’m often asked about the craft of outlining a cozy mystery, and while I sat plotting out characters and writing the scenes of my newest release, MURDER ON THE MENU, I had time to contemplate just that. A cozy mystery must be warm and comforting, pleasing to a reader’s palate, and best enjoyed under a blanket or on a fall day—much like a hearty helping of clam chowder.
And that got me thinking, if I had to compare a cozy mystery to a mouth-watering clam chowder (you can tell I’m quite hungry writing this, can’t you?), what would I include to balance it out? Here are the perfect ingredients for a cozy mystery.
The Base/Grease/Fat: A Charming Small Town
For easiest consumption, the cozy mystery must have a satisfying base. A charming small town with a fabricated name that gives the reader a chuckle or the impression of warmth. For example: Quizzical, Pennsylvania, or Gossip, Texas, or, most recently, Periwinkle Point, Maine.
The town itself is filled with antique stores, book shops, restaurants, paved sidewalks, a park or a lake, a guesthouse, a church, a town hall, and a library. Each of these has a fun name or a history of its own. Importantly, the town must feel lived in. It is a place to which the reader longs to return, not only because of the characters, but because of the aesthetic itself.
This is not a dingy town; it’s filled with light and activity, and it celebrates every holiday, from Thanksgiving to Valentine’s Day, with enthusiasm.
The Clams and Potatoes: A Quirky Cast of Characters
The population of a charming small town must be equal parts intriguing and kind, mysterious, and quirky. We have the victim, who may either be someone everyone secretly hated or a beloved pillar of the community with a dark secret—I’m hoping none of the clams in the chowders I consume have dark secrets, by the way. Eugh.
Next is the killer, who is either vengeful, desperate for money, or a jilted lover. There’s no end to the motives a killer might have, but importantly, they must not be too obvious to the reader. Kind but not too kind, secretive but reasonably so, and the clues they leave behind must be obvious, but not so obvious that the reader solves the case immediately.
The suspects might be clams, potatoes, carrots or onions, but they have one thing in common: they always have a desperate secret. That secret must be desperate enough to prevent them from giving the police or the sleuth information about the case lest it expose their dirty laundry.
And let us not forget the garlic, who adds flavor, and might be a handsome police officer, a local business owner, or a reporter who is romantically interested in the sleuth!
The Herbs and Spices: A Confusing Set of Clues
Clues in a cozy mystery are varied. There must be red herrings, letters or notes that seem important but aren’t, details that seem mundane but are actually integral to the story, or even a smoking gun or a blood-stained knife.
Importantly, the murder itself must not ruin the recipe by being “on-screen.” It usually happens out of sight, quite politely, and the sleuth who finds the body notes the details without telling the reader anything off-putting.
There might be fingerprints, swatches of cloth, discarded shoes, or broken heels. The murder weapon is an important piece of evidence which might provide the sleuth with information they didn’t have before.
Importantly, clues can be verbal as well. The killer has left a trail behind, gossip, rumors, and items that point to who they are.
The Thickener: A Sleuth Who Just Won’t Quit
Drawing it together is, of course, the sleuth. She/he is likely middle-aged, but doesn't have to be, and is down on their luck. They’ve usually come out of a terrible relationship, job, or living situation, and have returned to their hometown, or started afresh in a new town, to run a bakery or teashop. Sometimes the sleuth, as in the case of MURDER ON THE MENU, is desperate to prove herself to her parents working in a restaurant that serves up, believe it or not, a lot of clam chowder.
The sleuth is tenacious, they are interested in solving a crime to protect their loved ones or the town, and they will stop at nothing to make sure the killer is brought to justice.
The Final Ingredient
The chowder must be left to develop—meaning that the clues and red herrings, and the characters themselves, must have room to grow within the story when it is being written. An important component of a cozy mystery is how everything combines to create a story that makes sense.
But as with any recipe or creative endeavor, feel free to test and try new ingredients. Add in a dash of magic for a witchy mystery or a recipe. Remember that the best ingredient of all is always enjoyment, both for the writer and the reader.
A Periwinkle Point Word Search Mystery #1

Welcome to the oceanside town of Periwinkle Point, Maine! It’s where cozy mystery meets word search fun for the perfect killer combo. Written by the USA TODAY bestselling author of the Cranberry Creek series, Murder on the Menu introduces amateur sleuth Olivia Owens as she digs into the shocking murder of a new restaurant owner. This charming interactive whodunit combines a fun seaside mystery with 50 clever word searches (and a tasty recipe!) to create the quintessential cozy activity!
Olivia Owens loves living by the ocean in Periwinkle Point, Maine with its rugged coastline, smalltown charm, and mostly friendly neighbors. She has big dreams for her family’s local seafood spot and can’t wait to take over. But when a fancy new restaurant plans to open in town and the owner winds up dead, it’s up to Olivia to solve the case and clear her mother’s name. Puzzle along and figure out whodunit in Murder on the Menu.
Mystery Cozy [ Adams Media, On Sale: November 17, 2026, Paperback, ISBN: 9781507227794 / ]
Rosie A. Point is a USA TODAY bestselling cozy mystery author of more than ninety novels and novellas set in fictional small towns across the United States. She loves writing about food, amateur sleuths, cats, and secrets; her favorite books are ones you can snuggle up with under a cozy blanket on a winter's day. Rosie lives in Cape Town, South Africa with her son, husband, and adorable kitten, Shiva the Destroyer.
No comments posted.